Those Who Would Give Up Essential Liberty To Purchase A Little Temporary Safety Benjamin Franklin
"Those who would give up essential Liberty, to purchase a little temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety." Few lines from American history are quoted as often. It appears whenever a government proposes more surveillance, more police powers or new emergency rules, and it is almost always read the same way: individual freedom should never be traded for security.
Benjamin Franklin did write it. But he wrote it in a letter about a tax dispute in colonial Pennsylvania, and in that setting it meant something very different. The "liberty" he was defending was the right of a legislature to tax a wealthy family, and the "safety" he was dismissing was money for the frontier.
Where Does the Quote Come From?
The line appears in a letter dated November 11, 1755, sent by the Pennsylvania Assembly to the colony's governor, Robert Hunter Morris. Franklin was a leading member of the Assembly and wrote the letter on its behalf. The full sentence, with its original spelling and capitals, reads:
Those who would give up essential Liberty, to purchase a little temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety.
The same words were later printed on the title page of An Historical Review of the Constitution and Government of Pennsylvania (1759), a book published in London as part of the Assembly's case against the colony's owners. That second appearance helped the line circulate well beyond Pennsylvania.
The Penn Family Tax Dispute
To understand the quote you need to know who ran Pennsylvania. The colony was not owned by the Crown. It belonged to the descendants of William Penn, who held it as proprietors. By the 1750s that meant Thomas and Richard Penn, who lived in England and governed through a deputy governor they appointed. Morris was that governor, and he answered to them.
In 1755 the French and Indian War had reached Pennsylvania's frontier. Settlements were being attacked and the Assembly wanted to raise money for defense. The obvious source was a tax, and the Assembly insisted that the Penns' enormous landholdings should be taxed along with everyone else's.
The Penns refused. Their governor was under instructions not to approve any bill that taxed proprietary estates, so he vetoed the Assembly's defense bills one after another. The Penns then offered to contribute money toward defense themselves, on the condition that the Assembly drop its claim to tax them.
That is the deal Franklin's letter is responding to. The Assembly's position was that a one time payment, however useful in an emergency, was not worth surrendering its permanent right to raise taxes and govern the colony. Giving up that power to buy a little short term security was exactly the trade the letter calls unworthy.
What Franklin Actually Meant
Read in context, every term in the sentence means something specific.
"Essential Liberty" is not personal freedom from government. It is the Assembly's freedom to govern, and above all its power to levy taxes on everyone in the colony, proprietors included.
"A little temporary Safety" is the money for frontier defense that the Penns were offering in exchange for an exemption.
The people who "deserve neither" are legislators who would accept that bargain and sell off their own authority for a single payment.
So the quote is not an argument against government power in the name of individual rights. It is an argument for the power of an elected legislature to tax and spend for the common defense. The Assembly was demanding the authority to do more, not less, and it was fighting the wealthiest family in the colony to get it. That is close to the opposite of how the line is usually used.
The quarrel with the Penns did not end in 1755. It dragged on for years, and in 1757 the Assembly sent Franklin to London to argue its case against the proprietors directly.
How the Quote Is Used Today
In its modern form the quote usually argues that people should resist new security measures because they cost freedom. It was quoted widely after the September 11 attacks during debates over the PATRIOT Act, again during arguments over government surveillance programs, and again during public health restrictions. The phrase is flexible enough that people on every side of an argument have used it against the other.
In 2011 the legal writer Benjamin Wittes drew attention to the original context of the line, and since then many historians and journalists have pointed out the gap between what Franklin wrote and what he is usually quoted as saying. The popular reading has not changed much. Like Jefferson's warning about slavery, the line is often remembered as a timeless principle with the specific circumstances that produced it stripped away.
Common Misquotations
The quote is frequently shortened or reworded. Common versions include "Those who would sacrifice liberty for security deserve neither" and "Those who give up liberty for safety deserve neither and will lose both." The last clause, "and will lose both," does not appear in Franklin's letter at all. Neither version keeps the words "essential" and "a little temporary," and those qualifiers matter. Franklin was not saying that any trade between liberty and safety is wrong. He was saying that giving up something essential and permanent for something small and temporary is a bad bargain.
Is the Quote Accurate?
Yes. The words are genuine and Franklin wrote them. What has changed is the meaning. A sentence written to defend a colonial legislature's right to tax the Penn family has become a slogan against government power in general, which is nearly the reverse of the argument Franklin was making in 1755.
For students and researchers
Cite this article
Choose a citation style, then copy the reference for your bibliography or notes.
“Those Who Would Give Up Essential Liberty To Purchase A Little Temporary Safety Benjamin Franklin.” Quotes Explained, 10 Oct. 2026, https://quotesexplained.com/those-who-would-give-up-essential-liberty-benjamin-franklin/.
Those Who Would Give Up Essential Liberty To Purchase A Little Temporary Safety Benjamin Franklin. (2026, October 10). Quotes Explained. https://quotesexplained.com/those-who-would-give-up-essential-liberty-benjamin-franklin/
Quotes Explained. “Those Who Would Give Up Essential Liberty To Purchase A Little Temporary Safety Benjamin Franklin.” October 10, 2026. https://quotesexplained.com/those-who-would-give-up-essential-liberty-benjamin-franklin/.
“Those Who Would Give Up Essential Liberty To Purchase A Little Temporary Safety Benjamin Franklin,” Quotes Explained, October 10, 2026, https://quotesexplained.com/those-who-would-give-up-essential-liberty-benjamin-franklin/.
This cites the Quotes Explained article, not the historical quotation's original source. To cite the original document, follow the source references in the article. Confirm the final format against your instructor's requirements.