Why Thomas Paine Wrote “These Are the Times That Try Men's Souls”

In December 1776, American independence looked much less secure than it had in July. The Continental Army had retreated across New Jersey. Enlistments were nearing expiration, the British held New York City, and the revolution needed men to keep fighting despite a run of defeats.

Thomas Paine had published Common Sense earlier that year, making a forceful case for breaking with Britain. Now he had a different task. Independence had been declared. Could the people who supported it endure the cost?

The opening words, in print

The first number of The American Crisis opened:

THESE are the times that try men's souls:

The capitalization and colon above follow a 1776 broadside preserved by the Library of Congress. Modern editions often normalize the capital letters and replace the colon with a period. Those editorial choices do not change the words, but they are a useful reminder that even familiar quotations have physical source texts.

What was happening in 1776?

The Declaration of Independence had not ended the war. British troops had defeated Washington's forces around New York and pursued them through New Jersey. A soldier deciding whether to reenlist faced exhaustion, uncertain pay, and the prospect of another campaign against a better supplied army.

Paine drew a line between commitment that survives only while a cause is easy and commitment that endures when the cause is in danger. Immediately after the famous opening, he contrasted the summer soldier and the sunshine patriot with the person who stays when the struggle becomes costly.

That is why his language is so urgent. This was not a quiet observation that everyone sometimes has a hard year. It was an appeal to people who could choose to abandon a revolution while it was still in progress.

What did Paine mean by trying men's souls?

To be tried meant to be tested. The crisis would disclose what people truly believed through their conduct. Paine did not pretend the conflict would be painless. He argued that difficulty gave the struggle for freedom weight.

The same passage says that victories too easily obtained are too lightly valued. Paine tied endurance to the price of liberty: people might need to give up comfort and safety before their principles could mean much.

There is a risk in quoting the first line by itself. It can sound like advice for any personal setback. In its original setting, it asked a specific political question. Would Americans who had welcomed independence remain committed to it as the military situation worsened?

Did Washington read the pamphlet to the troops?

The story that Washington had the essay read to his soldiers before the crossing of the Delaware is widely repeated. The pamphlet certainly belongs to the same perilous December campaign, but a famous anecdote should not be treated as a verbatim eyewitness record without separate documentation.

What we can say securely is that the line appeared in a printed 1776 work, circulated as a political appeal during a military emergency. That evidence is strong enough to explain why Paine wrote it.

Original source and historical record

Paine's sentence survived because it gives a memorable shape to the question faced by an army in retreat: whether people will stand by a cause after its easy moments have passed.

For students and researchers

Cite this article

Choose a citation style, then copy the reference for your bibliography or notes.

“Why Thomas Paine Wrote “These Are the Times That Try Men's Souls”.” Quotes Explained, 22 Oct. 2026, https://quotesexplained.com/these-are-the-times-that-try-mens-souls-thomas-paine/.

This cites the Quotes Explained article, not the historical quotation's original source. To cite the original document, follow the source references in the article. Confirm the final format against your instructor's requirements.

See also

Related quotes